Doe v. Boyertown Area School District

To book an interview, click on the "Book an Interview" button on any page at ADFmedia.org.
Thursday, November 29, 2018

Description:  During the 2016-17 school year—without informing parents or students—the Boyertown Area School District secretly opened its high school locker rooms, showers, and restrooms to students of the opposite sex, which violated many students’ bodily privacy rights. Some of the students in the suit involuntarily encountered students of the opposite sex in various states of undress in school restrooms and locker rooms.


Pa. students ask US Supreme Court to reverse decision that allows violation of their bodily privacy

ADF represents students, parents challenging locker room, restroom policy
Monday, November 19, 2018

Video | Photos

 
PHILADELPHIA – Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys representing Pennsylvania students and their parents, along with Independence Law Center, asked the U.S. Supreme Court Monday to take up their case after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit ruled that the students’ privacy didn’t merit protection.

During the 2016-17 school year—without informing parents or students—the Boyertown Area School District opened its high school locker rooms and restrooms to students of the opposite sex based on those students’ beliefs about their gender. Some male students learned of the policy while they were undressing in their locker room and discovered that a female student was changing clothes with them. Embarrassed and confused, the students sought help from school officials, who told them they should just “tolerate it” and “make it as natural as possible.”

After parents got involved, the officials told students their alternative was to stop using the boys’ locker room. Another Boyertown student, Alexis Lightcap, learned of the policy when she encountered a boy in her restroom. She was shocked, afraid, and fled the room, but school officials refused to listen to her privacy concerns either.

“Everyone should be able to agree that students struggling with their beliefs about gender need compassionate support,” said ADF Senior Counsel and Vice President of Appellate Advocacy John Bursch. “But there are sound reasons why schools have always separated male and female teenagers in showers, restrooms, and locker rooms. No student’s recognized right to bodily privacy should be made contingent on what other students believe about their own gender. The 3rd Circuit’s decision made a mess of bodily privacy and Title IX principles, and the decision deserves review and reversal by the U.S. Supreme Court.”

The lawsuit, Doe v. Boyertown Area School District, claims that the school is violating its students’ fundamental right to bodily privacy under the U.S. Constitution and effectively denying them access to locker room and restroom facilities on the basis of sex under Title IX. ADF attorneys and allied attorneys filed the petition with the Supreme Court because the full 3rd Circuit declined in July to rehear the case.

“These types of school policies have serious privacy implications,” said ADF Legal Counsel Christiana Holcomb. “Teenagers should not be forced to welcome members of the opposite sex into their showers, restrooms, or locker rooms based on what they believe about their gender. All schools, including Boyertown Area School District, should be providing support for those dealing with gender dysphoria, but they should seek to do so in ways that protect the privacy of all students.”

As the petition to the Supreme Court in the case explains, “It is untenable that the Third Circuit made students’ right to bodily privacy contingent on what others believe about their own gender.” The brief continues, “Recognizing this reality does not diminish the concern for students who believe they are of the opposite sex. Schools can (and should) teach that every student has inherent dignity and worth and should be treated as such. Schools can (and should) assure students with gender dysphoria that they are valuable and important members of the school community. And school officials can (and should) provide them with resources and support. Despite such alternatives, Boyertown chose to violate the privacy rights of all other students.”

“Schools should not expect students to accept that the differences between females and males don’t matter in the very places set apart for privacy from the opposite sex,” said Randall Wenger, chief counsel of Independence Law Center, whose attorneys serve as co-counsel and are among more than 3,200 attorneys allied with ADF. Independence Law Center is a Pennsylvania-based pro-bono legal organization dedicated to advancing civil rights.

Alliance Defending Freedom is an alliance-building, non-profit legal organization that advocates for the right of people to freely live out their faith.
 
# # # | Ref. 58757

Additional resources: Doe v. Boyertown Area School District

Scroll down to view additional resources pertaining to this case and its surrounding issue.
Thursday, November 29, 2018

Previous news releases:

  • 2018-07-02: Pennsylvania students appeal decision that allows violation of their bodily privacy
  • 2018-05-24: Students, parents may appeal 3rd Circuit student privacy decision
  • 2018-05-23: Pa. student to come forward: ‘Please stop my school from violating my privacy’
  • 2017-09-25: Students, parents ask appeals court to stop Pa. school district from violating bodily privacy
  • 2017-08-25: Court allows Pennsylvania school district to continue violating student privacy
  • 2017-08-10: Students, parents ask court to stop Pa. school district from violating bodily privacy
  • 2017-04-18: Three students join bodily privacy suit against Pennsylvania school district
  • 2017-03-21: Student sues Pennsylvania school district for sexual harassment, violation of personal privacy
  • 2017-03-20: News conference Tuesday to announce student privacy lawsuit against Pa. school district

Commentary:

  • Alexis Lightcap: My high school’s transgender bathroom policies violate the privacy of the rest of us (USA Today, 2018-11-29)
  • Alexis Lightcap: Girls and boys shouldn't do everything together (Philadelphia Inquirer, 2018-05-24)
  • Kellie Fiedorek: Dignity and fairness matter for every child in the locker room (Daily Signal, 2017-04-14)

Legal documents, related news, and other related resources available in the right panel when this page is viewed at ADFmedia.org.